What is a "human child" considered? Up to what age are they a child? I think this designation should be made first. Depending on the age group, a few years can matter a significant amount.

[ Saber figures an eighteen year old would be much capable than a sixteen year old, usually, but.. ]

And I agree Tarn should not be on the committee. With how many people are bringing up previous concerns with him, it is not something we should ignore.